Objective: Despite the existence of a national reconstruction and rehabilitation program, agency-level guidelines, and the accumulated experience of implementing organizations, the design of post-disaster temporary accommodation in Iran still lacks a comprehensive, integrated framework of design components agreed upon across agencies. This gap has led to an excessive emphasis on physical aspects, disconnection between the different spatial scales of design, and insufficient learning from past experience. This study aims to systematically identify, extract, consolidate, and classify the components affecting temporary accommodation design, thereby providing a conceptual basis for developing design regulations and implementation guidelines.
Method: This applied study combines a systematic literature review based on the PRISMA 2020 guidelines with directed qualitative content analysis. Of 486 records identified, 96 sources, including international standards, scientific articles, national documents, research reports, and evaluations of past experiences, were included in the analysis. Coding was performed in three stages—open, axial, and selective—with a final inter-coder agreement of 91%. The resulting framework was validated through expert review and a coverage-adequacy test.
Results: A total of 612 initial codes were reduced to 127 final components, grouped into five main categories and 19 subcategories: physical and technical (46), environmental (17), socio-cultural (24), economic (14), and managerial and institutional (26). Approximately 64% of the components fall outside the physical and technical category. The most frequently cited component in the reviewed sources was the proximity of the site to the former place of residence, with 71 references, reflecting its socio-spatial nature. In addition, 72% of the components relate to the pre-disaster phase, and 45 components were assigned the highest priority level according to explicitly defined prioritization criteria.
Conclusions: Temporary accommodation design is a multidimensional issue; reducing it to uniform technical specifications overlooks much of the problem. A significant part of the final quality is determined by decisions made during the preparedness phase. Furthermore, no formally approved inter-agency mechanism for governing and coordinating temporary accommodation was identified in the national documents reviewed. |